Thread: A totally non-scientific experiment...

The list now is:

1) hi_bud_gl
2) Hoglahoo
3) pcb01
4) Kingfish
5) Pabster

The razors have arrived! And they are beautiful, as is the antique case they came in.

Just by peering at the bevels, I am already leaning to which razor I think was finished on which hone Tomorrow morning's shave will be fun. There's white dovo paste on my linen, so I'll keep the razors on leather. Thanks Stu!

Can I vote anyway? I think I know the right answer!!!

Originally Posted by Stubear

Sham has recieved the razors, shaved with them and these are his thoughts.

1) Coticule
2) Charnley Forest
3) Maruichi

More to follow..!

Which was his favorite? Did Jimbo vote for him?

I am going to need one more shave to determine my favorite, but my guesses are:

1) Maruichi
2) Coticule
3) Charnley Forest

Sham's favourite was number 3.

(Please correct me if I'm wrong though Sham...! )

Thanks for sharing your thoughts Lee..!

I dont know why Jimbo voted though..? He must have gotten a vibe from the pictures lol..!


EDIT: I should have said earlier as well, I shaved with them all and my favourite was number 1. I've added my vote to the poll.

my favorite is not number two. number one seems a tad sharper, but I am wondering if three is not a bit more comfortable

Just for the sake of the argument.

In case I take part I'll be number 6 or 7 on the list.

That means the razors have been used by 6 members before me and stropped at least as often. Wouldn't that diminish the differences?

Originally Posted by Kees

Just for the sake of the argument.

In case I take part I'll be number 6 or 7 on the list.

That means the razors have been used by 6 members before me and stropped at least as often. Wouldn't that diminish the differences?

I could see that happening especially if the people before you are going to more frequently strop the razors they like least than the razors they like best

Originally Posted by Stubear

Sham's favourite was number 3.

(Please correct me if I'm wrong though Sham...! )

Thanks for sharing your thoughts Lee..!

I dont know why Jimbo voted though..? He must have gotten a vibe from the pictures lol..!


EDIT: I should have said earlier as well, I shaved with them all and my favourite was number 1. I've added my vote to the poll.

Stu your are correct.
My best shaver (in my mind) was 3.

I shaved again tonight. 1 and 3 are different, but I like them both. If you force me, I think I'll choose 1 though

Mailing these out tomorrow