Thread: looking for a refill

Hello gentleman. I've been using a bottle of Stetson aftershave and am starting to get low. My dad had it from when he used to shave, so it's older than I am (I'm 18 and my dad hasn't shaved since since before I was even thought of). I tried a newer bottle and it just doesn't smell the same. So I've been looking for a replacement. I like the slightly spicy, woodsy smell with a kind of musky base. do any of yall have any ideas for a suitable replacement in the $30ish price range? I can't do balms, but I like the alcohol burn. Thanks for your help folks, I wish you all smooth shaves and cool drinks.

___________________________

Devilpup

Might not be the same, but try Pinaud Clubman. Plenty burn, and awesome scent.

I've been thinking about it and the old spice but I wasn't sure about the scent.

_____________________________________

Devilpup

Ogalalla Bay Rum, Sage & Cedar is great stuff. Has a hint of the bay rum sweetness with a good bit of spice and wood coming through.

4 oz Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershaves

Originally Posted by bharner

Ogalalla Bay Rum, Sage & Cedar is great stuff. Has a hint of the bay rum sweetness with a good bit of spice and wood coming through.

4 oz Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershaves

+1

Although you might as well buy the sample pack of 2nd bottles to try some variety.

Originally Posted by Devilpup

Hello gentleman. I've been using a bottle of Stetson aftershave and am starting to get low. My dad had it from when he used to shave, so it's older than I am (I'm 18 and my dad hasn't shaved since since before I was even thought of). I tried a newer bottle and it just doesn't smell the same. So I've been looking for a replacement. I like the slightly spicy, woodsy smell with a kind of musky base. do any of yall have any ideas for a suitable replacement in the $30ish price range? I can't do balms, but I like the alcohol burn. Thanks for your help folks, I wish you all smooth shaves and cool drinks.

___________________________

Devilpup

Keep in mind an aftershave that old might have altered a bit so it's hard to know how it originally smelled after all those years.

Thanks Gents. thebigspendur i honestly hadn't thought of that, all I know is the new stuff smells completely different to me. It's funny the girls tell me I smell like an old man, but they dont seem to mind enough to go away or for that matter stop taking such deep breaths around me. :-)

My friend, for you I'd recommend Tabac, which can be had for well under $30. If you like the classics you'll like Tabac

+1 for the Pinaud Clubman. Only about $7.00 at the local drug store.

Devilpup,

Go to the fragrancenet website. They list several men's colognes with a cent similar to Stetson, including British Sterling, Jordan and Ferrari Black.

You can most likely find these colognes at your local drugstore, Target, Wal-Mart or department store and try some with a tester before purchasing an alternative.